
A person may wish to use a home to fund scholarships, set aside money to support a relative or ensure that a building continues to serve as a synagogue after their death. Alongside that intention, decisions are needed about who will manage the assets, how income will be used and what happens when circumstances change.
An endowment can place these matters within a legal framework intended to continue over time. Even in an established endowment, where the property and beneficiaries are familiar, decisions about letting, renovation or sale begin with the founding documents and the powers given to the trustees. This article concerns arrangements governed by Israeli law.
What an endowment is and how it relates to a trust
A trust is a legal relationship concerning property, under which a trustee holds it or acts in relation to it for another person or a designated purpose. An endowment, known in Israel as a hekdesh, is one way of establishing such an arrangement through the dedication of assets and instructions for their management.
There are three central roles. The settlor dedicates the property. The trustee manages it and carries out the instructions. The beneficiaries are the people or public for whose benefit the assets or their income are intended. Sometimes the endowment serves a defined objective, such as education or assistance to people in need, without naming each recipient in advance.
It is useful to distinguish from the outset between preserving the asset itself and using its income. Someone who wishes to retain a home for many years and distribute only the rent should make that intention clear. If a sale or use of capital is also contemplated, the conditions should be addressed.
Private, public and religious endowments
A private endowment generally serves specified beneficiaries, such as relatives whom the settlor wishes to support. It may provide for asset management and conditional distributions of income instead of an immediate transfer of all the property. Its suitability depends on the beneficiaries' needs and the applicable law.
A public endowment promotes a public interest, such as education, health, religion or welfare. Under the route governed by the Israeli Trust Law, the Registrar of Endowments supervises the arrangement and trustees have registration and reporting obligations. Combining a family purpose with a public purpose requires examination of the classification and resulting duties.
A religious endowment requires a separate review of its creation and governing framework. Israel's Rabbinical Courts deal with religious endowments within their jurisdiction, assisted by the religious endowments registration and supervision unit. Use of a building as a synagogue, or a religious purpose expressed by the settlor, does not by itself identify the competent forum. The deed, the date and manner of creation and previous decisions must be examined.
Creating an endowment
The starting point is an accurate definition of the assets and purpose. Establish which rights belong to the settlor, whether there are charges or third party rights and what can actually be dedicated.
Under the Trust Law route, the endowment instrument must express the intention to establish the endowment and define its purposes, assets and conditions. The law recognises, among other forms, a document signed before a notary and a will other than an oral will. It also links the commencement of the endowment to the transfer of control of its assets to the trustee.
A public endowment also requires attention to registration with the Registrar. As a general rule, a trustee must notify the Registrar of its existence within three months of becoming a trustee, unless notification has already been given, and report changes to particulars that require reporting. Creating the arrangement is distinct from completing its registration and the relevant asset register formalities.
What the endowment instrument should address
The instrument should anticipate situations that may arise years after it is signed. It should address the identity and replacement of trustees, how decisions are made, how beneficiaries are selected and how income is distributed.
Where land or a building is dedicated, attention should be given to powers to let, renovate and sell, the possibility of acquiring a replacement property and how expenses are funded. For financial assets, it is important to define how capital is preserved and what may be distributed, subject to the law.
Personal choices also need precise wording. Is support for a relative a fixed amount or based on need? Are scholarships restricted to a particular group? What happens if there are no suitable applicants? Addressing these questions helps trustees exercise judgment without having to guess the settlor's intentions.
Establishing an endowment through a will
A will can establish an endowment to be managed after the testator's death. For example, a property may be retained and its income used to support a relative or a public activity, subject to the prescribed conditions.
Planning should distinguish the estate administrator's role from the trustee's role. Estate administration concerns the deceased's assets and liabilities, while the endowment may continue for many years afterwards. The provisions should be coordinated, including who receives control of the assets and what happens if the chosen person cannot serve.
An arrangement intended to continue across generations calls for a joint review of succession and trust law. Merely using the word endowment does not permit every restriction on property or remove every difficulty that might arise under an ordinary will.
Trustees' responsibilities
A trustee must preserve and manage the assets and pursue the endowment's purposes. Where the Trust Law applies, the trustee must act faithfully and diligently in accordance with the statutory standards. Assistance from a lawyer, accountant or property manager does not replace the judgment required of the trustee.
In practice, a clear file should record decisions, agreements, receipts and expenditure. Endowment funds should be kept separate from personal funds, and the applicable reporting obligations should be checked. A public endowment may also be required to provide information and documents to the Registrar and, within the appropriate framework, may apply for a certificate of proper management.
A transaction with a trustee, a relative or a connected party requires particular scrutiny. Even a financially attractive proposal can involve a conflict of interest and require prior approval. If a trustee dies, resigns or stops functioning, continuity of office and signing authority must be addressed under the governing documents and law rather than left to an informal practice.
Managing property that funds the endowment
An income producing property should be assessed by its ability to fund the endowment's purposes over time. Monthly rent matters, but repairs, insurance, vacant periods, collection costs and management expenses also need to be considered.
The lease should be reviewed periodically for its suitability to the property and market, the adequacy of security and any investment needed to preserve value. Where cash reserves exist, the needs of the activity and the applicable rules for holding and investing funds should be considered before deciding how to use them.
For example, a home producing reasonable rent but requiring major renovation calls for a comparison between renovation, continued ownership and sale. A useful comparison shows the amount remaining for the endowment under each option and the risk of interrupted income. The decision must also comply with the trustees' powers and the settlor's instructions.
Selling property and acquiring a replacement
A sale can be part of managing an endowment, but agreement between the trustees does not establish that the transaction may proceed. First check whether the instrument permits a sale, which restrictions are recorded against the property and which approvals are needed.
For a public endowment supervised by the Registrar, the sale procedure includes a reasoned application for approval in principle, compliance with the transaction requirements and arrangements for removal of the endowment notice from the register. Where the instrument itself requires amendment, District Court approval may also be needed. A religious endowment within a Rabbinical Court's jurisdiction must follow the applicable route and decisions.
Preparing the application should include a valuation, income and expense figures, reasons for selling and a plan for the proceeds. If a replacement purchase is proposed, the plan should also account for taxes, adaptation costs and a possible period without income. Commitments to buyers and sellers should be coordinated with the approvals required for the endowment.
When circumstances change
A community's composition may change, a building may become unsuitable or it may become difficult to find beneficiaries who meet old conditions. The first task is to distinguish the original purpose from the means prescribed for achieving it.
An endowment intended to conduct an activity at a specific place differs from one intended to finance that activity through income from the property. That distinction can affect the possibility of letting, selling or proposing another use.
The Trust Law gives the court power to change provisions subject to statutory conditions. Under the Registrar's guidance, a proposed change to a public endowment that does not accord with its instrument requires a court application, with a draft first submitted to the unit for review. The proposal should explain what has changed and how the settlor's intention is preserved. Good intentions or support from some beneficiaries do not replace the required authority and approval.
Disputes and applications for directions
Disputes may concern the beneficiaries, the extent of assistance, property management or trustees' conduct. Before adopting a position, gather the instrument, earlier decisions and financial information and identify the provision or action at issue.
Sometimes clarification of the facts and an agreed way of working can resolve the dispute, provided that the agreement is lawful and does not change rights or purposes without authority. Where no suitable solution is available, an application to the competent forum for directions, or sometimes for the appointment or replacement of a trustee, should be considered.
Trustees of religious endowments within the Rabbinical Courts' jurisdiction must report to the court and seek directions for significant actions. Applications for directions under the civil framework can also provide a response before a doubtful step is taken.
Tax and property transactions
The public or religious dedication of property does not itself confer exemption from all taxes. Creation of the endowment, ongoing income, a sale and the acquisition of another property should each be considered separately.
A property transaction can raise questions about Israeli real estate capital gains tax (Mas Shevach), purchase tax and betterment levy. Relief available to a public institution is subject to the relevant conditions and status. Approval under section 46 of the Income Tax Ordinance concerns tax credits for donors and may also be relevant under other provisions, but is not a blanket exemption for every endowment transaction.
Tax review requires information about how and when the asset was acquired, its use and existing approvals. The Tax Authority distinguishes an application for exemption from real estate capital gains tax from an application for purchase tax relief. The review should therefore precede calculations of net sale proceeds or commitments to a replacement purchase.
Documents for an initial review
The document list depends on the endowment and proposed action. It usually starts with the endowment deed or will, any probate order, court decisions and trustee appointments. Land register extracts or rights certificates, leases, financial reports, tax approvals and correspondence with the supervisor should also be gathered.
If a transaction is contemplated, include a valuation and concrete proposals. Missing old documents do not prevent an initial review of the available material and enquiries about the original file. The aim is to identify what can be done now, what needs completing and which decisions must be obtained before proceeding.
Frequently asked questions
Is every donation an endowment?
No. The terms and designated purpose of the transfer must be examined. An ordinary donation and the transfer of an asset for continuing management for a particular purpose may be different arrangements even if both benefit the same organisation.
Can an endowment be created without real estate?
Yes. It may consist of money or other assets. The dedicated assets should be identified and the management instructions adapted to their nature.
Must a private endowment register with the Registrar of Endowments?
A private endowment with no public purpose is not entered in the public endowments register merely because it is an endowment. An additional public purpose requires a different assessment. Registration requirements relating to the assets themselves must be checked separately in every case.
Does a trustee personally own the asset?
Acting as trustee does not give freedom to use the asset for personal needs. Even where rights are registered in the trustees' names, they act within the trust and subject to their obligations.
Can property be sold to increase income?
This can be considered, but the instrument, alternatives and necessary approvals must be reviewed. Comparisons should address net income, costs and risks as well as the endowment's purposes.
Can the settlor's family change the endowment?
A family relationship alone does not confer that authority. The position granted to relatives in the documents and the legal conditions for a change must be examined.
What if the original purpose can no longer be achieved?
Examine the reason, the governing provisions and the possibility of variation or termination through the appropriate procedure. It does not follow that the funds or property may be freely divided between trustees or family members.
This article provides general information about Israeli law. Creating and managing an endowment requires examination of the governing documents, the type of arrangement, the powers of those involved and the applicable law.
View the practice area