Your starting point
What happened with the authority?
Choose a situation to see what to check first, or continue reading the full article.
In each situation, keep the decision or correspondence, record when it was received and check whether a binding deadline applies.
This selection provides general information only. It does not determine the appropriate procedure or calculate a filing deadline.
What is administrative law?
Administrative law governs the exercise of public powers and the relationship between public authorities and those affected by their decisions. It concerns individuals, businesses, nonprofit organisations and public bodies, and includes review of the way authorities act.
An issue may arise with a government ministry, a local authority, a committee or another body carrying out a public function. Sometimes there is a clear written decision; in other cases, the problem is a failure to decide, a prolonged delay or action taken without an adequate explanation.
The identity of the other party does not by itself determine the procedure. A dispute with a municipality about its exercise of public power differs, for example, from a payment dispute arising from a contract with it. Public law and contract law may both be relevant. The appropriate forum depends on the nature of the dispute and the remedy sought.
What is expected of a public authority?
An authority is given powers to perform a public function. Legal review examines the source of that power, the decision-making process and the exercise of discretion. Several principles recur across many cases:
Acting within lawful powers
The legal basis for the action, the person or body authorised to take it and the conditions for exercising that power must be identified.
A sufficient factual basis
A decision should rest on adequate factual material. An overlooked document or an inaccurate fact may affect the assessment.
Equality and relevant considerations
Comparable cases should be treated on relevant grounds. Different treatment may be justified by a material difference in circumstances, rather than an irrelevant consideration.
Fairness and the right to be heard
Before a decision adversely affecting a person, a fair opportunity to present their case is generally required. The scope and form of that opportunity depend on the circumstances and the applicable law.
Giving reasons
Reasons make it possible to understand what was considered and why an application was refused. The duty to give reasons is subject to the applicable legal rules and exceptions.
Reasonableness and proportionality
Review considers the weight given to relevant factors and the relationship between the public objective and the harm caused. Its scope depends on the power exercised and the context.
A general assertion that a decision is unfair is usually insufficient. The specific problem needs to be identified: a fact that was missed, a consideration that was ignored, a difference from comparable cases or a lost opportunity to present arguments. Even an established defect does not necessarily invalidate the decision; its significance and the appropriate outcome must be assessed in context.
The work begins before the application is submitted
An initial application is an opportunity to present an organised account. Check the relevant route, the current procedure and the conditions that need to be addressed. An impressive document that does not address eligibility may leave the central question unanswered.
The application should explain what is requested, the legal framework relied on and the supporting facts. Attach relevant documents, identify the appendices and explain gaps or information likely to raise questions. Where several bodies hold information, check that it is consistent and up to date.
After submission, retain a complete copy and proof of delivery, a reference number or the online system's receipt. If further information is requested, explain which document addresses each requirement. An incomplete response that does not explain what is missing can prolong the process.
What decision are you asking for? What establishes that the conditions are met? Is there a deadline or urgent circumstance the authority should consider?
An application is refused: start with the reasons
Read the refusal alongside the original application and its attachments. Does it concern a missing document, a finding of ineligibility, the interpretation of a procedure or an exercise of discretion? Each reason may call for a different response.
If the facts are inaccurate, identify the error and provide supporting evidence. If the dispute concerns the legal conditions, examine the framework relied on by the authority. If the authority considers that the circumstances do not justify an exception, establish whether it has power to make one and what it considered when exercising that power.
At the same time, check when the decision was received, the rules for an objection or appeal and the body to which it must be submitted. Do not assume that another letter to the same official is the required procedure or preserves the deadline for another remedy.
A nonprofit organisation receives a refusal stating that a document is missing. Before making broader arguments, check whether the published conditions require that document, whether it was already attached, when it was delivered and whether it may still be supplied. Addressing the precise point in dispute may be more effective than resending the entire file.
When the authority does not respond
A reply saying that an application is being processed does not always explain what has been done. First establish whether the competent body received it, whether documents are missing and whether a particular obstacle prevents a decision. A substantive update and an indication of the expected next steps can then be requested.
An authority must act within the deadlines applicable to it and within a reasonable time. Israel's Administrative Procedure Amendment (Decisions and Reasons) Law contains provisions on responses and reasons, alongside exceptions and specific arrangements. The type of application and its governing law therefore need to be checked, rather than applying one deadline to every request.
When a delay continues, an organised record shows when the application was submitted, which additional documents were provided and the responses received at each stage. Depending on the matter, an approach to a supervising official, an appropriate complaint or proceedings seeking to require a decision may be considered. Delay alone does not make an application approved unless a specific legal arrangement provides otherwise.
A hearing: an opportunity to influence the decision
A hearing allows a person who may be adversely affected to present their position before the authority decides. Meaningful participation requires an understanding of the proposed decision, the allegations supporting it and the documents relevant to assessing the matter.
Preparation includes assembling the facts, answering the allegations and providing supporting documents. Sometimes it is also appropriate to propose a practical alternative, such as meeting a requirement, correcting a deficiency or adopting conditions that reduce the harm. The proposal must be consistent with the authority's powers and the circumstances.
A hearing is not necessarily a meeting. Written submissions may be appropriate, depending on the governing law and the matter involved. If information is missing or there is insufficient time to prepare properly, raise this promptly. A request for an extension is not an extension: the existing deadline should be treated as binding until a different decision is made.
Which documents can be requested from the authority?
The missing item may be the very document that explains the decision: minutes, an opinion, a procedure or information placed before the decision-maker. A focused request should identify the document or information and, where necessary, explain its connection to the matter.
A person's request to inspect material concerning their own proceedings should be distinguished from a request under the Freedom of Information Law. These routes have different legal bases and may involve restrictions relating to privacy, confidentiality and the rights of others. There is no automatic right to receive every document in full.
A freedom of information request may be suitable, for example, for obtaining guidelines or information held by an authority. It is not an immediate solution to every urgent evidential need, and filing it should not be assumed to suspend a deadline for an objection or court proceedings. Obtaining documents and preserving procedural deadlines may need to be pursued in parallel.
A request, an objection, an appeal or a petition?
The terms can sound similar but describe different routes. The choice depends on the decision and its governing framework. A letter to a public enquiries department, for example, is not necessarily a substitute for an appeal required by law.
| Route | What is its purpose? | What needs checking? |
|---|---|---|
| Request to the authority | Obtaining a decision, clarification, correction of information or further consideration. | The competent body and whether another mandatory procedure applies alongside it. |
| Objection or appeal | Challenging a decision internally or before a designated body. | Jurisdiction, the deadline, filing requirements and the scope of review. |
| Complaint | Examining shortcomings in service or conduct within the complaints body's powers. | Whether the matter can be examined, particularly if an appeal route or court proceedings exist. |
| Court proceedings | Seeking legal review and a remedy from the competent court. | The type of proceedings, exhaustion of remedies, deadlines and any need for interim relief. |
As a general rule, before going to court the authority should have a genuine opportunity to address the arguments, and the applicable preliminary remedies should be exhausted where required. This does not mean repeatedly sending the same request without purpose. What is required in the particular circumstances, and whether urgency calls for a different course, must be assessed.
When is an administrative petition appropriate?
An administrative petition is one route for reviewing an authority's decision in Israel. The jurisdiction of the Court for Administrative Affairs is determined by law according to the subject and the decision-making body. There are also administrative appeals, proceedings before specialist tribunals and, in appropriate cases, petitions to the Supreme Court sitting as the High Court of Justice. A route cannot be chosen simply because a government ministry made the decision.
For example, some decisions concerning entry into and status in Israel are initially reviewed by the Appeals Tribunal under the applicable statutory provisions. An administrative appeal may then be available. This is one reason to establish the sequence of proceedings before filing a document headed 'petition'.
What outcome can be sought?
The remedy may involve requiring a decision, setting one aside, referring the matter back for further consideration or another remedy within the court's powers. Courts do not generally replace the authority in every professional choice entrusted to it. Even where intervention is justified, the outcome is not necessarily the grant of the licence or approval originally sought.
Deadlines: when is immediate action needed?
The time available for an objection, appeal or petition may be short. It is also necessary to check the event from which time runs: publication, delivery, knowledge or another event specified by the relevant rules. Delay may prejudice the availability of relief even before the maximum filing period has expired.
Do not assume that a request for reconsideration, a conversation with an official or a promise to review the file extends the time available. Establish the legal effect of the step taken and whether a separate application is needed to protect procedural rights.
If an action is imminent and would be difficult to reverse, consider an application for a stay or other appropriate interim relief. Such relief is not automatic. Depending on the procedure and circumstances, relevant considerations include the prospects of the proceedings, the harm to the parties and the public interest.
In practical terms, establish three dates at the outset: when the decision became known, the deadline for challenging it and when it is due to be implemented. These may be different dates.
Administrative law in daily life
Licensing, business and imports
A business may need to deal with several authorities, each with separate powers. Approval from one does not guarantee that operations may begin. The work includes mapping the requirements, preparing suitable documents and examining conditions in a licence or decision. If approval is refused, identify the requirement that has halted the process.
Nonprofit organisations, grants and allocations
An application for funding or the allocation of public property requires careful reading of the scheme's conditions and deadlines. Meeting eligibility requirements should be distinguished from actually receiving funding or an allocation. If an application is refused, examine the reasons, the documents submitted and how the criteria were applied to the case.
Status in Israel
Status applications may involve documents from different countries, evidence of family circumstances and a sequence of decisions. Handling them requires familiarity with the particular procedure and the routes for reviewing decisions. The website includes further articles on residency in Israel, status for foreign partners and humanitarian status.
Local authorities and public tenders
Matters involving a local authority may concern property use, licensing, allocations and public contracts. Prompt action can be especially important in tender disputes because selection and contracting may continue while a disagreement is being examined. The tender documents, published notices and decisions are the starting point for review.
What should you prepare for an initial assessment?
You do not need to wait until every document is available. Begin with the material you have, identify what is missing and check whether an approaching deadline requires action.
The checklist is for your convenience only. Nothing is sent to the firm, and selections are cleared when the page is refreshed.
Frequently asked questions
Can I deal with the authority myself?
Many requests and applications can be submitted independently. If there is a refusal, a hearing, a legal dispute or a short deadline, consider the appropriate approach before proceeding. Documents submitted at an early stage may also affect the case later.
Does every decision I disagree with justify a petition?
No. A legal ground must be identified, the appropriate procedure checked and the potential benefit assessed. Disagreement with the outcome does not by itself show that the authority exceeded its powers or exercised its discretion unlawfully.
I was told of a refusal by telephone. Should I wait for a letter?
Request a written decision and reasons, and record the conversation and its date. However, do not assume that every deadline begins only when a letter arrives. The legal significance of the notification and knowledge of the decision must be checked under the applicable rules.
Does a further request suspend the appeal deadline?
Not necessarily. A request for another review does not automatically extend the time limit. Check whether the law allows an extension, who may grant it and whether one has actually been granted.
The authority is asking for a document I already sent. What should I do?
Provide the document with proof of its earlier delivery and ask whether the issue concerns receipt or its contents. An updated document or a different type of document may be required. A written explanation helps identify the precise requirement.
Must a hearing take place in person?
Not in every case. Written submissions may be sufficient. The question is whether there was a fair and meaningful opportunity to answer the allegations, taking account of the law and the nature of the potential harm.
Could a complaint to the Ombudsman be suitable?
Sometimes. Israel's Ombudsman examines complaints about public bodies within its jurisdiction, without charge and without requiring legal representation. Some matters are generally excluded, including matters before a court and decisions subject to a statutory objection or appeal route, subject to exceptions. A complaint does not automatically replace the procedure provided by law.
Can compensation be claimed for harm caused by an authority?
Possibly, but a defect in a decision does not automatically create an entitlement to compensation. The cause of action, loss, causal connection and appropriate procedure require separate assessment. Proceedings aimed at changing a decision are not necessarily the proceedings in which a financial claim will be heard.
How long does the process take, and what does it cost?
This depends on the matter, the route chosen, missing documents and urgency. Legal fees, official fees and incidental expenses should be distinguished. Court proceedings also carry the possibility of a costs order, and interim relief may involve financial conditions. The scope and cost of each stage should be considered in advance.
If the authority changes its decision, is the matter finished?
Read the new decision and check what it actually permits, whether conditions have been added and when it will be implemented. If proceedings have already begun, their conclusion must also be addressed. Agreement in principle does not always complete the action for which the matter was opened.
Legal assistance in dealing with public authorities
Legal assistance begins with the practical objective: obtaining approval, renewing a licence, completing an assessment, changing a condition or preventing harmful action. That objective guides the sequence of steps, the checking of deadlines and the collection of documents needed to present the matter clearly.
Yaacov Amsellem Law Office assists individuals, businesses and public bodies in dealings with government ministries and local authorities. The work includes preparing applications and correspondence, presenting arguments, addressing authority decisions and representation in the appropriate proceedings, according to the circumstances.
Have you received a decision or are you waiting for a response?
For an initial meeting, bring the decision, the application submitted and the latest correspondence. Mention at the outset any scheduled hearing, review deadline or date for implementing the decision.
This article provides general information and does not replace an individual assessment of the law, documents and deadlines applicable to the case.
